www-russia.org

Chapter 56: The Believer

Ivan, a retired army major with a back as straight as his worldview, returned home from his confrontation with the schoolteacher in a state of white-hot rage. “Poison!” he declared to his wife, slamming his hand on the kitchen table. “They are feeding our children poison! Turning them against their own fathers, their own history!”

He had been a patriot his entire life. He had served in Chechnya. He had believed, with the unyielding certainty of a true soldier, in the righteousness of the Motherland and the wisdom of its Commander-in-Chief. This new, liberal nonsense was a disease.

But later that evening, the first crack appeared in the fortress of his certainty. His son, Piotr, was sitting at his desk, the heretical new history book open before him.

“I told you not to read that filth,” Ivan growled.

Piotr looked up, his expression not rebellious, but genuinely confused. “But Papa,” he asked, his voice quiet, “the book just uses the official casualty reports from the TRC. Are you saying the TRC is lying? General Volkov himself testified. Was he lying too?”

The question threw Ivan off balance. He couldn’t process it. Volkov was a hero, a patriot who had saved the state. But the conclusions of his commission were unthinkable. “It’s complicated,” he snapped. “It’s a political game. You are too young to understand.” He forbade his son from reading the book, but a seed of terrible, gnawing dissonance had been planted.

He began to watch the archived TRC broadcasts late at night, alone in the dark of the living room. He watched not to learn, but to find the flaws, the lies, the proof that it was all just a Western-backed show trial. He scoffed at the weeping mothers, dismissed the economists as traitors. But the testimony of General Volkov… the cold, brutal honesty of it… it troubled him deeply.

The next week, a traveling session of the Truth Commission came to his own provincial city. Ivan went, his jaw set with a grim resolve. He would wait for the right moment, and then he, Major Ivan Kuznetsov, a respected veteran, would stand and speak the truth, to denounce this circus in front of his whole community.

He sat in the back of the hall, waiting. A young man took the witness stand. He was not a politician or an intellectual. He was a local kid, a former contract soldier who had worked in the tractor factory. He began to speak, his voice a low monotone, about his time in the war. He spoke of incompetent commanders, of bad intelligence, of being sent on pointless assaults. And then he described a friendly fire incident, a mapping error that had caused his own side’s artillery to rain down on his platoon, killing six of his friends. An incident that Ivan knew, from his own contacts, had been officially blamed on the enemy.

The soldier began to weep, not from fear, but from the sheer, soul-crushing waste of it all.

Ivan sat frozen in his chair, the speech he had prepared dying in his throat. The boy’s testimony was so viscerally, undeniably true, so familiar in its every specific, stupid, brutal detail, that it bypassed all his ideological defenses. He wasn't just hearing a story. He was reliving the ghosts of his own past. He remembered the faces of his own young men, lost to some general’s arrogant stupidity in the mountains of Chechnya. He remembered the lies he himself had been forced to write in his own after-action reports.

The fortress of his certainty, which had been under siege for weeks, finally, silently, and completely collapsed.

He did not stand up. He did not say a word. He just sat in the back of the hall, a patriot, a believer, a man who had built his entire life on a foundation of faith in the state. And for the first time since he was a small boy, he began to weep, silent tears of grief for the country he had loved, and for the lies he had loved even more.

The Discourse, 56: The Cognitive Dissonance of the "True Believer"

Section 56.1: The "Fortress of Certainty"
Ivan's initial mindset represents the psychological state of the "true believer." His identity is not just aligned with the state's narrative; it is completely fused with it. His patriotism, his military service, and his personal honor are all built upon the foundational belief that the state is fundamentally righteous. For such a person, contradictory information (like the new textbook) is not processed as a simple disagreement, but as a direct, personal attack on their identity and worldview, hence his initial, furious reaction.

Section 56.2: The Power of the "Credible Messenger"
The initial crack in Ivan's fortress is caused by his son's question about General Volkov. The subsequent, total collapse is caused by the testimony of the local soldier. These two figures represent the "credible messenger" phenomenon. Ivan is psychologically equipped to dismiss the testimony of victims, intellectuals, or politicians as the work of traitors or fools. However, he cannot easily dismiss the words of a national hero like Volkov, or a simple, working-class soldier whose experiences so closely mirror his own. These messengers are "credible" because they come from within his own moral and social world. Their testimony cannot be easily compartmentalized as "enemy propaganda," forcing him into a state of acute cognitive dissonance.

Section 56.3: The "Evidentiary Tipping Point" and Identity Collapse
Ivan's final breakdown is an "evidentiary tipping point." Cognitive dissonance is a deeply uncomfortable state, and the brain actively seeks to resolve it. He initially tries to resolve it by seeking "confirmation bias"—watching the hearings to find evidence that they are a sham. But the accumulated weight of credible testimony, culminating in the soldier's viscerally true story, becomes overwhelming. The old narrative can no longer be sustained. The moment he accepts the soldier's story as true, his entire "fortress of certainty" collapses. This is a profoundly painful and disorienting psychological event, a form of identity death. His tears are not just for the lies he was told, but for the man he used to be, the man who believed in those lies with all his heart. This painful process, multiplied by millions, is the substance of a true national reckoning.